Herman Cohen Proposes “mutually face saving solutions” to Ethio-Eritrea problem

•”Mutually face saving solutions”
•“Eritrean leadership fears Islamic militancy as much as any other country in the Horn of Africa region”
•“UN Security Council should terminate sanctions imposed in 2009 by UNSC resolution 1907”
•“Ethiopia offer to accept a symbolic initial takeover by Eritrea of territory awarded by the EEBC”

Photo Source: Tesfanews
Photo Source: Tesfanews

By Dimetros Birku

(Borkena) Herman Cohen, former assistant secretary of state for Africa, seem to be making a case for normalization of relations not just between Eritrea and Ethiopia but also between Eritrea and the international community.

In an article published on the African Argument, Cohen painted a roadmap that depicts as to how both objectives could be achieved.

Recounting the circumstances under which UNSC resolution 1907 was passed by the United Nations Security Council which apparently made Eritrea appear a pariah State, Cohen argues that the situation is no longer there and the “UN Security Council should terminate sanctions imposed in 2009 by UNSC resolution 1907.”

Susan Rice, then US Ambassador in the UN, proposed resolution to pass sanction against Eritrea on alleged grounds that Eritrea is helping Al-Shabab in Somalia.

Mr. Cohen argues that “as far as external support for Shabaab is concerned, all available intelligence indicates that Eritrea has not had any contact since 2009.” It was implied in his argument that Eritrea has no involvement in facilitation of funds for Al-Shabab after 2009.

“Those of us who know Eritrea well understand that the Eritrean leadership fears Islamic militancy as much as any other country in the Horn of Africa region,” Mr. Cohen added.

With regard to how the UN sanction could be ended, Mr. Cohen proposed that one of the European member of the Security Council to initiate a resolution at the UN Security Council to end sanction against Eritrea and for the US to be at least abstinent. The reason, for him, is that European countries had good relations with Eritrea

On Ethio-Eritrean relation

Recalling how the state of Eritrea was created and how the two nations slipped to war following what he referred to as “excellent relations” by EPLF and TPLF headed governments between 1993 and 1998, he seem to think that the two countries no longer need to be at loggerheads.

Cohen identified problems regarding “border dispute” and the problem with regard to implementing Eritrea and Ethiopia Border Commission (EEBC) ruling. For Cohen, the problem could be ended with “a mutually face-saving solution”: “Ethiopia offer to accept a symbolic initial takeover by Eritrea of territory awarded by the EEBC, followed by the same day opening of dialogue with a totally open agenda.” His argument for ending hostility between the two countries is mainly grounded on economic rationale and he thinks Ethiopia could benefit much from a continent port facility of Eritrea. Meanwhile, Addis Fortune reported that Djibouti issued ultimatum to the government of Ethiopia regarding cargo release on the port of Djibouti.

Mr. Herman Cohen also quoted President Isaias Afeworki as saying ‘Eritrea cannot fulfill its destiny without Ethiopia.”

It is to be recalled that Herman Cohen played crucial role as a sort of peace broker in the negotiation process which sort of laid the foundation for the legitimization of breaking up of Ethiopia into two states leading to the emergence of Eritrea as independent state. Is Mr. Cohen oblivious about the fact that Ethiopia was left land locked because of the political process to which he was a part in one way or another?

Over all the tone of Mr. Cohen’s argument is for Ethiopia and Eritrea to leave behind the hostility and foster economic co-operation. He portrayed Eritrea in a positive light to the international community and to Ethiopia as well.

Impossible to comment at this point if Mr. Cohen’s article is an informed and possibly a precursor to a formal negotiation process between the two countries which may mean a continuation of backdoor talk. If there is such a project and if it is a success, it is likely that it will have implications, probably negative, for the alleged power struggle within TPLF (between alleged pro-Eritrean elites that seem to have greater power and the other faction within TPLF). As well, it could have negative implications for Ethiopian rebel groups’ operation along Ethio-Eritrean border.

7 Responses to "Herman Cohen Proposes “mutually face saving solutions” to Ethio-Eritrea problem"

  1. ጥሩነህ   December 19, 2013 at 1:28 am

    ትልቁ ቂጣ ሊጥ ሆነ፥
    ያመኑት ፈረስ ጣለ በደንደስ ማለት እሄው ነው,,,What a news, all we build for armed struggle to get our freedom through Eritrea will be gone….

    Reply
    • Prudence   February 10, 2016 at 10:08 am

      Deep thought! Thanks for cotbnitunirg.

      Reply
  2. Ewnetu Belete   January 16, 2014 at 6:03 am

    Mr. Cohen,

    Your proposal appears to appease a dictator who has lost the respect of his own people. You want to prolong the tyrant’s life at the expense of Ethiopia.

    You state the rationale for the normalizing relations between Ethiopia and Eritrea is economic. this is a flimsy excuse. Ethiopia is doing great without Eritrea’a ports of Massawa and Assab.

    Genuine normalization of relations between Ethiopia and Eritrea cannot come by granting Badme to Eritrea but only when Eritrea has a sane leader who is dedicating peace in the horn of Africa. Not by a leader who tortures his own people and uses them as fodder in illegal wars.

    So please be true to yourself and promote genuine peace in the horn of Africa.

    Reply
    • Efu   February 8, 2014 at 6:47 pm

      You Ethiopian or Eritrean, No one can talk about Eritreans ,who to be thier president.

      Reply
  3. Addis   February 5, 2014 at 6:29 am

    What a crazy idea!!!!

    We Ethiopians do not need Eritrea any more. In stead Ethiopia should build a fence on its border to block any Eritrea to enter Ethiopia. We have to fight for 1000 years to destroy this Arab dog Eritrea

    God Bless Ethiopia

    Reply
  4. Alem gebremeskel   February 7, 2014 at 3:46 pm

    dear Cohen,
    it is known that “War is sweet for those who know it not”, perhaps,as you said ;yes it is ‘the right time’,and not only to the two dictators;but also to the two true lovers of peace people. this is the one you ought to have as a first.

    second, and the ‘most real fearing’ to the true thinkers,-the war of the very terrorist, not only for the sake of the Eritrean people, but also even for the world is said to be most admireble if it could be practical as what you have started.

    Reply
  5. Oromiya Biyyakoo   January 21, 2017 at 3:37 pm

    Propganda or Hypocrisy or both? In the first place I wonder how Mr. Herman Cohen continues speaking of peaceful negotiations when a country as that of Ethiopia is run by fake governments never ever have been elected democratically. It remains for the last 25 years a brutal country with daily records of abusing Humans Rights, with thousands of hundreds of political prisoners, and killings on daily bases up to this very moments. So is Mr. Herman Cochen pretending to be deaf and blind to all these? Is he playing a secret role to cover Ethiopia’s mess? Is he doing all these hypocritical announcement for distracting reasons to cover the ongoing turmoils and persecutions of the Oromos and the millions about to die of poverty and hunger? Does he have any reason to get into such a propaganda in favour of gaining time for the Ethiopian regime? Ethiopia is undergoing both a racial political crisis on one hand as well as a deliberate plan of genocide on the other, that is being carried by the TPLF. Are all these to be ignored? Are all these let pass as though all other issues are solved except that of the Ethio Eritrean one? What the hell is Mr. Herman Cochen doing? Does he thing he can cover also Ethiopia’s populations that are starving of poverty and dying in millions, “Deliberately?” What is exactly that Mr. Hermn Cochen is after after all?

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.